Reply in public, briefly and soon. Say what went wrong in plain words, say what you have done about it, and give a direct way to reach you. Leave out anything private about the guest and anything that sounds like an argument.
Future guests will read the reply as well as the person who wrote the review. Write it for them. Google also notifies the reviewer when you reply, and they can still change what they wrote.
What every reply needs
Google's own guidance for owners is short. Keep the reply brief, because "Customers value direct and honest responses." "Acknowledge if any mistakes were made, but don't take responsibility for things outside your control." Sign with a name or initials, so the guest knows a person read it.
Replies go through Google's checks before they appear. Google says this usually takes up to ten minutes and can sometimes take up to thirty days, so a reply that does not show at once has not necessarily failed.
A fair complaint about food or service
Resist the urge to explain. Agree with what is true, say what changed, invite them back without a bribe.
For example: "Thank you for telling us. A forty-minute wait for mains on Friday is too long, and the lamb should not have reached you lukewarm. We were two cooks short that night and have since changed how we staff Fridays. I would like to hear more if you are willing. Please ask for me next time or write to our email." Then sign it with your first name and role.
A complaint you believe is wrong
State your side once, calmly, with the fact that matters. Do not go line by line. A long rebuttal reads as a restaurant that fights its guests, whoever is right.
For example: "I am sorry the evening ended badly. Our booking shows the table was held for twenty minutes past the reserved time before we released it, which is the policy on our booking page. I understand that was frustrating on a birthday. If you would like to talk it through, please call and ask for me." Sign this one too.
A claim that the food made someone ill
Reply the same day with a holding message and move the conversation to the phone. Do not confirm or deny a cause in public. You do not know it yet, and neither does the guest.
For example: "We take this seriously and want to look into it today. Please call us or write to our email with the date of your visit and what you ate, so we can check our records." Then check them: the dishes, the batch, the staff on shift, any other complaint from that service. If the guest mentions a doctor, a claim or a report to public health, call your insurer or your lawyer before you write anything further.
A reviewer who never visited, or who used to work for you
Report the review first. Google's policy does not allow content "not based on a real experience", and it treats "current or former employment" as a conflict of interest.
Then post a short reply for other readers: "We cannot find a visit matching this review. If we have missed it, please contact us with the date and we will look again." Do not name the person, and do not say in public that they were dismissed. That is their private information, and Google's guidance is "Never share a reviewer's private information or engage in personal attacks."
What never goes in a reply
Three things. Details that identify the guest beyond what they posted themselves: a surname, a phone number, who they dined with, what was on the bill.
An offer in exchange for a change. Google prohibits merchants from offering "payment, discounts, free goods and/or services" for the "revision or removal of a negative review". You may put a mistake right. You may not tie it to the rating.
And a promotion. Google's advice is to be "conversational, not promotional", because "Your reviewers are already customers".
Common questions
Should a restaurant reply to every review?
Reply to every negative one. For positive reviews, Google advises against sending the same thank-you to everyone and suggests focusing on reviews where you can share an update or answer a question.
Who should write the replies?
Someone who can find out what happened that night and has the authority to put it right, usually the owner or general manager. For our clients we answer comments, messages and reviews as part of the monthly work.
Will a good reply get the review changed?
Sometimes. Google notifies the reviewer and lets them edit the review after reading your reply, and says a reply may encourage an update. Do not ask for the change in the reply itself. Fix the problem and let the guest decide.
Sources