For most independent restaurants a points program is worth running only when guests can visit often, the reward is simple, and staff can enrol people in a few seconds. That describes a café, a lunch counter or a neighbourhood takeout. A restaurant people visit a few times a year gains more from a guest list with a welcome, a birthday and a win-back email.
Here is how to tell which one you are, and what to check before you start.
Frequency decides it
A reward changes behaviour when the next visit is close. A guest who buys coffee four times a week can reach a tenth cup this month and will choose you over the café next door to get there. A guest who comes for an anniversary dinner will not eat out more often for points.
Count how often your regulars come. If the answer is weekly or more, a program can work. If it is every few months, put the effort into being remembered at the right moment.
Why the usual claims overstate the gain
Loyalty providers report that members visit and spend more than other guests. That is true and proves less than it seems. The guests who join are the ones who already came often. The program did not make them regulars. They were regulars who signed up.
The honest test is whether the same guests visit more after joining than they did before, and whether that extra spend is larger than the rewards you gave away. Be cautious of any figure that compares members with everyone else.
What a program costs to run
The reward is the first cost, and much of it goes to guests who would have come anyway. Every free tenth coffee given to a daily regular is margin you had already earned.
Then there is the software fee, the seconds at the till on every order, and staff training. A program that slows the line at lunch costs more than it shows on any report. There is also a promise to keep. Points a guest has earned are owed to them, and ending a program badly loses the people it was built for.
The simpler option is a guest list
A list of guests who agreed to hear from you does most of what a program does. A welcome message after a first visit. A birthday invitation. A note to someone who has not been in for three months. These can be set up once and sent automatically.
This is the work we do under email and loyalty: welcome, birthday and win-back emails, guest segments, and reporting on repeat visits. In Canada you need consent before sending commercial messages, and the sender has to be able to prove it, so collect permission properly from the first sign-up.
Rules to check in Ontario
Alcohol. The AGCO's guidelines for liquor sales licensees say liquor may not be purchased for patrons as part of a promotion or at regular intervals, and that promotions such as 2 for 1 drinks are prohibited under all circumstances. If your reward is a drink, or is earned by buying drinks, check with the AGCO or a lawyer before launch. Rewards paid in food are the safer design for a licensed room.
Expiry. Before you print an expiry date on points or stamps, ask a lawyer whether your province limits when rewards may expire. It is a quick question, and it is cheaper to ask before the cards are printed.
If you go ahead, keep it small
Choose one reward a guest can explain to a friend in a sentence. Make it reachable within a month for a regular. Measure visits per member before and after, and review after six months with the cost of rewards beside the extra sales.
Common questions
Is a paper stamp card enough?
For a café, often yes. It costs almost nothing and guests understand it. What it does not give you is a way to contact the guest, so pair it with an invitation to join your email list.
Should a restaurant with several locations run a loyalty program?
It has a stronger case. Guests can earn at one location and redeem at another, the cost of the software is spread across more sales, and the data shows which locations share guests.
What is a good reward for a full-service restaurant?
Recognition tends to work better than discounts. A held table, a first look at a new menu or a dish sent out on a birthday costs little and is remembered. Discounts teach guests to wait for the next one.
Sources