A restaurant in Canada may ask guests for an email address or phone number when they sign in to its WiFi, provided the screen says plainly what the details will be used for. Sending marketing to those guests requires their consent under the anti-spam law. Whether that consent may be made a condition of getting online is unsettled.
The cautious design is a separate, optional box for marketing that a guest can leave empty and still connect. This article explains why, quoting the official sources. It is not legal advice.
Two laws apply to one sign-in screen
Privacy law governs collecting and using the guest's personal information. For a restaurant in Ontario that is the federal law, PIPEDA. The Privacy Commissioner's office notes that Alberta, British Columbia and Quebec have their own private-sector privacy laws, which generally apply in place of PIPEDA to collection within those provinces. A Vancouver venue should read the B.C. law.
The anti-spam law, CASL, governs the messages you send afterwards. It is enforced by the CRTC. A sign-in screen has to satisfy both.
What you may ask for
Ask for the least that serves a purpose you can state. An email address to send the guest news, if they agree. Asking for a date of birth, a home address or a social media login to hand out a WiFi password is hard to justify.
The Privacy Commissioner's consent guidelines say purposes must be described in meaningful language, and that purposes integral to the service should be distinguished from those that are not. Getting a guest online does not, on its face, need their email address. Marketing is a second purpose and should be shown as one.
What consent to marketing requires
CASL prohibits sending a commercial electronic message unless the person has consented. A request for express consent must set out, in clear and simple terms, the purpose and who is asking.
On a sign-in screen that means one plain sentence: the restaurant's name, what will be sent, and that the guest can unsubscribe. Every message sent afterwards must identify the sender and carry an unsubscribe mechanism, and the restaurant bears the onus of proving consent.
Why the condition question is unsettled
Many sign-in pages make marketing the price of access: no email and agreement, no WiFi. The anti-spam statute sets out how consent must be requested. Its text does not say whether consent may be required in exchange for a service.
The Privacy Commissioner's guidelines address the point directly. They say individuals cannot be required to consent to the collection, use or disclosure of personal information beyond what is necessary to provide the product or service, and must be given a choice. A use the guest cannot refuse is called a condition of service, and to be valid it must be integral to providing the service.
Guidance under the two laws has been read as pointing in different directions on this, and we know of no ruling that settles it for restaurant WiFi. Until there is one, treat it as open and ask a lawyer.
The cautious design
Let every guest connect by accepting the terms of use. Below that, place a separate box for marketing, unticked, with its own sentence. Guests who tick it join the list. Guests who do not still get online.
This satisfies the stricter of the two readings, so it stands whichever way the question is settled. The list will be smaller. It will also be made of people who chose to hear from you, and they are the ones who open what you send.
Say what else is recorded
Guest WiFi systems can record more than the form: the device, the time of each visit and how often a guest returns. That is where the value lies for an operator, and our own guest WiFi service reports visit frequency.
Ask your provider exactly what is recorded and for how long. Say so in plain words on the sign-in screen or one tap away, and keep a dated copy of the screen each time it changes. It is your record of what guests agreed to.
Common questions
Is guest WiFi sign-in worth it for a restaurant?
It suits venues where guests stay and use their phones, such as cafés and bars. In a dining room where the meal takes an hour and few people ask for the password, a QR code on the table or a box on the booking form will usually collect more sign-ups.
Can we email everyone who has ever connected to our WiFi?
Only those who consented to marketing in a way you can prove. If past guests gave an email address to get online and were not asked about marketing, do not add them to the newsletter. Start asking properly from today.
Does a guest have to be able to withdraw later?
Yes. Every marketing message must carry an unsubscribe mechanism under the anti-spam law. The Privacy Commissioner's guidelines also say individuals have the right to withdraw consent, subject to legal or contractual restrictions.
Sources